Howl might be a one-of-a-kind film experience if not for Chicago 10, another film that blended documentary, dramatization and animation together into a blender of personal history. But what sets this film apart from that and all others is that poetry becomes interwoven into a courtroom trial procedural - all, apparently, taken from the actual court transcripts of what the prosecution/defense asked of the people on the stand - so that it becomes about free speech. At the same time it's a quasi-biopic on Allen Ginsberg, who was a real free spirit, but also a shy Jewish kid from New York city who lost his mother as a child and worried about writing poems that might irk the ire of his father (he even considered not publishing Howl for that reason).
It's a beautifully surreal little treat of a film that treats its subject seriously while also giving life to the epic poem that stays timeless, as with Walt Whitman's Leaves of Grass (which also gets name- dropped here). The filmmakers bring together the poetic readings - done by James Franco, one of his real 'embodiment' performances like Saul in Pineapple Express that is basically stunning - from in front of a live audience (where one sees how Ginsberg at first has an audience patient and waiting and then is full of life and looking forward to every next thing he says) and in animation. The poem becomes alive through the low-budget drawings, and depending on the stanza it can be at least acceptable and at most mind-blowing. You almost want the poem to go longer to sink in deeper to those Ginsberg stanzas that flow out with what appears to be stream of consciousness, but really has a structure to it.
Acting is fantastic - David Straithairn, Jon Hamm and in a one-scene keeper Jeff Daniels - Franco keeps things moving so well with his performance, and the poem is given it's best context in personal and social history. All of a sudden, thanks to a film like this, the material becomes alive again, like a student picking it up and sinking into it for the first time.
Howl
2010
Action / Biography / Drama / Romance
Howl
2010
Action / Biography / Drama / Romance
Plot summary
It's San Francisco in 1957, and an American masterpiece is put on trial. Howl, the film, recounts this dark moment using three interwoven threads: the tumultuous life events that led a young Allen Ginsberg to find his true voice as an artist, society's reaction (the obscenity trial),and animation that echoes the poem's surreal style. All three coalesce in hybrid that dramatizes the birth of a counterculture.
Uploaded by: FREEMAN
Director
Top cast
Movie Reviews
about poetry and the so-called laws of art
An Essential Film of Great Ideas
This is a brilliant film. I have not seen a another film that successfully shows how someone creates a work of art, especially a literary work. This film does it brilliantly, largely by quotations from the poem read very effectively by James Franco, who plays Ginsberg. Acted out interviews illuminate many things and the trial itself is extremely involving to watch. Even the animated portions we see while we hear parts of the poem work well. It's a remarkable film about artistic creation and how the artist must be allowed to use his own words and to use language that expresses his meaning fully, not language that is inoffensive to some imaginary reader.
Franco, John Hamm, David Strathairn, Bob Balaban, Jeff Daniels are all at their best, and seem truly committed to the project.
You don't even have to be a fan of Ginsberg, or know much about who he was to enjoy this. I was really impressed, one of the best films of this year, but it will likely be ignored by many.
beatnik's apex
Probably nothing symbolizes the beatnik era more than Allen Ginsberg's poem "Howl", not just because of its subject matter but also because of the obscenity trial that it sparked. Rob Epstein and Jeffrey Friedman's movie "Howl" tells the story of this. The film consists of three interspersed sequences: Ginsberg (James Franco) discusses his world views, the poem gets depicted in animation, and the trial. Franco is great as the anti-conformist poet, talking about his experiences with Jack Kerouac and Neal Cassady, and speaking frankly about his homosexuality. The part about the trial of course confirms that free speech is useless if everyone is forced to employ "agreeable" language, especially when addressing society's problems.
So, "Howl" is truly one that I recommend. Some people might still argue, as Ralph McIntosh (David Strathairn) does, that certain speech is inappropriate in certain conditions, but the purpose of the First Amendment is that people are supposed to be allowed to say whatever they want, even if it's not the most popular thing to say.
Also starring Jon Hamm, Alessandro Nivola, Jeff Daniels, Mary-Louise Parker, Bob Balaban, Treat Williams, Aaron Tveit and Jon Prescott.